GTM · COMPARISON · PAPER ONLY
Tradersland vs Trade Ideas
Trade Ideas is a real-time stock scanner and Holly AI idea platform with OddsMaker backtests. Tradersland is a plan-graded paper desk: you write rules, log paper fills, and each fill is scored against that plan. Paper only — no live orders.
What each does
Side-by-side from the product board (TradingView · TrendSpider · Trade Ideas). Trade Ideas price cells link to the public source with an as-of date — no invented list prices.
| Feature | Tradersland | Trade Ideas |
|---|---|---|
| Core job | Plan-graded paper desk (write plan → log fill → grade A–F) | Real-time scanners, Holly AI idea flow, OddsMaker backtests |
| Setup time | Minutes — open /demo/journal (seeded paper grades, no install) | Web Dashboard in browser (no download); TI Pro desktop for Windows · trade-ideas.com/features |
| Plan grading | Each discretionary fill scored vs your written plan; named rule breaks | Optimizes signal discovery — not a personal plan graded per fill |
| Scanners / shortlist | Public /demo/screener + /shortlist (breakout · pullback · structure flags) | Real-time Streaming Alerts, Top Lists, customizable scans/screeners |
| Odds / backtesting | Plan-rule /demo/backtest + /lab grades every paper fill A–F | OddsMaker backtesting + Holly AI Signals (Premium plan) |
| Languages | Deutsch + English UI (public pages default DE) | English (trade-ideas.com site lang=en) · trade-ideas.com |
| Pricing (monthly list) | CHF 29/Monat (Paper) on /pricing · waitlist door | Standard (Core) USD 127/mo · Premium (Apex) USD 254/mo (monthly list; annual equiv. $89 / $178) · trade-ideas.com/pricing |
| Pricing (enterprise / custom) | Flat CHF 29/Monat paper plan only (no paid-API fallback) | auf Anfrage / on request (Professional / Contact Us) · trade-ideas.com/pricing |
| Paper trading | Yes — /journal, /chart ticket, /demo/portfolio (PAPER only) | Real-time paper trading on Standard/Premium; not plan-graded A–F |
| Live orders / real money | Never — paper only, kein echtes Geld | In-app trading / Brokerage Plus / Money Machine on paid plans |
Start with paper
Paper trading only. Open the public demo journal — no checkout from this page.
Impressum · Datenschutz · PAPER ONLY